33 Comments
User's avatar
Joe DiSano's avatar

“who dresses like he raided the lost-and-found at a Waffle House” Thank you. That was God’s work.

Expand full comment
Stephen Breyer's Ice Cream's avatar

Oh, don't be mean to poor Jim Zorn. That poor dude was Peter Principle'd past even where HE thought he should be. At least he had the good sense to stick with the job past where anyone else would have quit just to stick it to Snyder.

Expand full comment
Terry's avatar

It is true that many lousy coaches are just victims of the Peter Principle. Is it really their fault?

Expand full comment
Jay's avatar

An "alarming aura of haughtiness" you say? Is Joe Judge secretly a JoJo character? ゴゴゴ

Great article 👏

Expand full comment
Mike Tanier's avatar

Perhaps not-so-secretly given his name. He would have some sort of weird Punting Stan.

Expand full comment
Matt Nielsen's avatar

I love the gloves off approach here. Most reporters are wanting to maintain relationships and access. I don't think Matt Patricia is taking your call anytime soon. Nice work!

Expand full comment
Mike Tanier's avatar

I have always been a small enough fish that I was able to take my shots at coaches. I was told both Mangini and Rex thought I was funny when I was ripping them in NYT. It's different when you don't have to show up at a team facility day after day. But tune in next week for the time I almost got into a fistfight with an NFL head coach!

Expand full comment
Scott de Brestian's avatar

Buddy Ryan?

Expand full comment
Mike Tanier's avatar

Nah. Never had the pleasure of meeting him. And the Ryan twins are always very nice when you run into them in social settings (which happens an awful lot in Mobile, Indy, etc.)

Expand full comment
Dwight Jon Zimmerman's avatar

In the second to the last paragraph you wrote "Spurrier" when I think you meant "Meyer."

Expand full comment
Mike Tanier's avatar

Thanks! Made a coupla corrections.

Expand full comment
Ralph's avatar

Ahhh, what fond memories! 😆

Expand full comment
Mike Lyons's avatar

Am enjoying the new venue and thought you had more time this week to polish the piece (small Spurrier issue aside). Really enjoyed this and am looking forward to reading all of your writings without wondering if the provider is still in business!

Expand full comment
Mike Tanier's avatar

I usually run everything through 4-5 edits. But there is a diminishing return element to editing: if you don't notice a mistake the second time it's because you are blind to it! Maybe this will get big enough that I can hire my eldest (soon to get his English Ed degree) to edit!

Expand full comment
Lost Ti-Cats Fan's avatar

I never understand how anybody can edit their own writing. I always read what I meant to say, rather than what I actually said. My only hope at self-editing is waiting until after I forget what I wrote, which fortunately is becoming a shorter and shorter wait period as I age.

Expand full comment
t.d.'s avatar

Chip Kelly actually quit his job as UCLA head coach to become Ohio State's new offensive coordinator, some time in the last week or so

Expand full comment
Ananda Gupta's avatar

Epic. (Also: there are two #4s and no #8)

Expand full comment
Todd's avatar

No Ray Handley?

Expand full comment
Mike Tanier's avatar

Only coaches from 2000 to present were considered, for reasons of my sanity.

Expand full comment
Pete Olski's avatar

From 2000 to the present explains why Ray Rhodes (Green Bay Packers 1999) was left off the list.

Expand full comment
Todd's avatar

Ahh!! Thank you. How's Frank doing?

Expand full comment
Mike Tanier's avatar

He recently had his walkie. To the best of my knowledge he is asleep in the living room as I work in my back-porch office!

Expand full comment
Todd's avatar

Okay!

Expand full comment
Sauerball's avatar

I think Petrino is the OC at Arkansas not HC....for now, at least

Expand full comment
Ken Raining's avatar

Yeah, that’s right. Which is still insane! Man I should have gotten into coaching.

Expand full comment
Mike Tanier's avatar

Yep. Thanks guys!

Expand full comment
Bill Houston's avatar

You did the impossible: this was even better than pt. 1! Would love to see you and Schaatz review this list on the podcast.

Your Matt Patricia Waffle House line has deservedly gotten a lot of praise but this one will have me chuckling for months (maybe because I've been teenager):

"Some head coaches stammer nervously through their introductory press conferences. Some fall back on boring platitudes about being aggressive or establishing the run. Only Adam Gase acted like the teenager dropping LSD for the first time in a 1970s after school special:"

Expand full comment
DMF For 3's avatar

Also great Waffle House 🏠 🧇 Reference!

Expand full comment
DMF For 3's avatar

What a load of garbage! Man 4-1 are epic failures! Yikes 😬 🏈

Expand full comment
DMF For 3's avatar

Garbage coaches not the writing ✍️ I thought 💭 I’d clarify! Because the writing is epic! I’m here 4 THIS! 🏈

Expand full comment
Terry's avatar

Great list. I was wondering if Patricia would make it, but there he is. So deserving.

Expand full comment
GT Counter's avatar

Great read. Urb had to be the worst. I was a fan of his since I love Ohio State. But he didn’t even bring that offense! Darrel Bevell at OCO, he did some read option in Seattle 2012-14 that’s about it. NFL 101 mostly

Expand full comment